Just exited Pentacle Theatre's "The Lost Virginity Tour" in #SalemOR.
This was the worst show I've seen at Pentacle, and just barely avoids being the worst show I've seen in Salem. (That honor belongs to APE by Dano Madden, a convoluted Guy-In-Your-MFA ego trip of a play in which the obvious playwright-insert character, who is a playwright, receives a heartfelt apology from his wife after she has a miscarriage.)
Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •I don't hate this premise. It's a relatively contemporary script—I think it was first performed in 2018 or 2019—and the setting is contemporary as well. Following a group of four women in the latter halves of their lives as they reflect upon their earliest sexual experiences could actually be an interesting vehicle to explore how we change not only as individuals, but how a culture can change over the decades as well. And of course, sex is a subject that's always rife with meaning, from matters of love, intimacy, and vulnerability, to bodily autonomy and the right to pleasure, to the political power of women in a sexist society, and far more beyond.
Like the Star Wars prequel trilogy, I can see glimpses of a powerful, compelling piece of art with thought-provoking themes... but what was actually produced bears scant resemblance to that fantasy.
Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •Instead, as written, "The Lost Virginity Tour" is as clumsy as a first time, and not nearly as endearing. I mentioned the jokes were accompanied by all but the characters pausing and asking, "GET IT?"; but the script was equally uncomfortable with entrusting its audience to suss out themes on their own.
In the fifth scene (the play starts with a baking club meeting at the retirement community, then jumps into a series of four road trip stops, one for each woman), the playwright twice repeats what I guess is the "moral" of the story, that all the women wish they'd waited until marriage like Rita did. Twice! And with all the subtlety of a Saturday-morning PSA about recycling inserted between cartoons.
The script strives for heavy drama at times but does none of the work to earn it. It wants us to care about this friend group, but the characters are so busy quipping at each other that there's no room for true personalities to emerge. We're shown the women's histories through their virginity tours, where they each recollect their first time, but the script is hardly writte
... Show more...Instead, as written, "The Lost Virginity Tour" is as clumsy as a first time, and not nearly as endearing. I mentioned the jokes were accompanied by all but the characters pausing and asking, "GET IT?"; but the script was equally uncomfortable with entrusting its audience to suss out themes on their own.
In the fifth scene (the play starts with a baking club meeting at the retirement community, then jumps into a series of four road trip stops, one for each woman), the playwright twice repeats what I guess is the "moral" of the story, that all the women wish they'd waited until marriage like Rita did. Twice! And with all the subtlety of a Saturday-morning PSA about recycling inserted between cartoons.
The script strives for heavy drama at times but does none of the work to earn it. It wants us to care about this friend group, but the characters are so busy quipping at each other that there's no room for true personalities to emerge. We're shown the women's histories through their virginity tours, where they each recollect their first time, but the script is hardly written in a way that allows us to see them in a new light, illuminated by the past. The characterization is so thin, and the monologues so unrooted, that they have all the emotional relevance of a Wikipedia plot summary. And once they have the heartfelt moment to cap off the experience, the women exit for the next stop on the tour, and by the time that scene begins, they've completely forgotten about whatever realization they just had, at least as far as their behavior and motivations are concerned.
Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •In the first act, after learning that Kitty's high-class, white parents blackmailed her into breaking up with her first love because he was Mexican, the four women rescue Kitty from her guilt by surrounding her and forcing her to chant, "I forgive Kitty!" with them.
In the second act, Viola's lifelong trauma over having been raped is also made better with a group hug.
The script at least has the good sense to not make these feel-good "come to Jesus" moments perfect in their outcomes—Viola continues to express heartbreak and self-blame—but they are the emotional climaxes of their respective scenes. They are presented dramatically as the resolutions to the women's anguish, guilt, and torment.
The script wants us to believe that the power of friendship can truly heal any wound, but it happens so quickly, relies on relationships that are told to us rather than embodied, and the characters revert so quickly to exactly who they were at the top of the script (usually as soon as the next scene begins) that nothing feels real. It all feels like h
... Show more...In the first act, after learning that Kitty's high-class, white parents blackmailed her into breaking up with her first love because he was Mexican, the four women rescue Kitty from her guilt by surrounding her and forcing her to chant, "I forgive Kitty!" with them.
In the second act, Viola's lifelong trauma over having been raped is also made better with a group hug.
The script at least has the good sense to not make these feel-good "come to Jesus" moments perfect in their outcomes—Viola continues to express heartbreak and self-blame—but they are the emotional climaxes of their respective scenes. They are presented dramatically as the resolutions to the women's anguish, guilt, and torment.
The script wants us to believe that the power of friendship can truly heal any wound, but it happens so quickly, relies on relationships that are told to us rather than embodied, and the characters revert so quickly to exactly who they were at the top of the script (usually as soon as the next scene begins) that nothing feels real. It all feels like hollow, artificial drama.
Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •And not only do the characters not change, except to say, "I love you girls" and decide they're absolute BFFs, the script won't even properly name their conflicts after their big dramatic moments.
In Act 2, Kitty's monologue, she confesses that she broke up with her first love, a Mexican boy named Mario, under coercive pressure from her wealthy white parents. In Act 5, while the script has her trying to deliver some sort of moral, Nina describes this as "class warfare".
And in Act 4, Viola dramatically admits she was raped (downstage center, with a spotlight on her), but Nina's summary in Act 5 won't use that word, instead saying she was "sexually assaulted". Yes, that's accurate, but taken with the rest of the script, it doesn't merely feel like a different word choice, it feels like another example of this script's unwillingness to hold our gaze. Viola used the word "rape" for the bombshell dramatic moment in Act 4, but by Act 5, they've already hugged about it and moved on to Elaine's story—using the word again would highlight how nothing had actually been res
... Show more...And not only do the characters not change, except to say, "I love you girls" and decide they're absolute BFFs, the script won't even properly name their conflicts after their big dramatic moments.
In Act 2, Kitty's monologue, she confesses that she broke up with her first love, a Mexican boy named Mario, under coercive pressure from her wealthy white parents. In Act 5, while the script has her trying to deliver some sort of moral, Nina describes this as "class warfare".
And in Act 4, Viola dramatically admits she was raped (downstage center, with a spotlight on her), but Nina's summary in Act 5 won't use that word, instead saying she was "sexually assaulted". Yes, that's accurate, but taken with the rest of the script, it doesn't merely feel like a different word choice, it feels like another example of this script's unwillingness to hold our gaze. Viola used the word "rape" for the bombshell dramatic moment in Act 4, but by Act 5, they've already hugged about it and moved on to Elaine's story—using the word again would highlight how nothing had actually been resolved!
Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •It is certainly A Choice to, in the Year of Our Lord 2018, write a monologue delivered by a white woman in a cast of four white women about how her parents' racism hurt her, and not only give her a touching group healing beat but also refuse to ever feature or further explore Mario's story.
The road trip framing device is apt. These women are tourists to their own lives. They drop into an unfamiliar (to three of them) location, hear a story, and drink wine. Whatever the history, it only matters insomuch as it matters to them, and it will stop mattering by the time they get back to the interstate. Will Kitty try to make amends with Mario? Will Viola seek out her daughter Lori, who she gave up for adoption? Will Elaine look for her true love, Carl—especially when she learns he's still waiting for her?
The answer to all of these questions is "no", because "Lost Virginity Tour" is devoid of life outside of the four cast members. This is particularly apparent in Pentacle's production, where the only other humanoid figures are the AI-generated imag
... Show more...It is certainly A Choice to, in the Year of Our Lord 2018, write a monologue delivered by a white woman in a cast of four white women about how her parents' racism hurt her, and not only give her a touching group healing beat but also refuse to ever feature or further explore Mario's story.
The road trip framing device is apt. These women are tourists to their own lives. They drop into an unfamiliar (to three of them) location, hear a story, and drink wine. Whatever the history, it only matters insomuch as it matters to them, and it will stop mattering by the time they get back to the interstate. Will Kitty try to make amends with Mario? Will Viola seek out her daughter Lori, who she gave up for adoption? Will Elaine look for her true love, Carl—especially when she learns he's still waiting for her?
The answer to all of these questions is "no", because "Lost Virginity Tour" is devoid of life outside of the four cast members. This is particularly apparent in Pentacle's production, where the only other humanoid figures are the AI-generated image of a friendly mechanic that flashes onto the backdrop for 15 seconds during a scene change, and the students in the AI-generated college campus backdrop, two of which were inexplicably Facebook Bitmojis. "Lost Virginity Tour" is written with a lonely solipsism masquerading as white female empowerment: no one exists except the Bake Club women, who, without fail, meet every opportunity to reach out to other humans with excuses and withdrawal.
Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •Again, I'm struck with the thought that this could make for excellent storytelling! All it would take would be an author who is willing to be slightly critical of the suburban wine mom fantasy. Because there is something to be said about how the women's sorority gives them a feeling of empowerment and belonging even while they are actively making choices to retreat from the uncomfortable business of living in community.
But that's not what "Lost Virginity Tour" does. It has nary a whiff of critical awareness. There are no consequences. And as a result, it reads as an earnest celebration of these characters' selfishness. As far as the script is concerned, every choice they make is the right one.
Spencer
in reply to Spencer • •Moving beyond that, the script cannot contain its contradictions.
In essence, it is four monologues. Naturally, each monologue wants to feel a little different, so the show has a tonal range and doesn't feel repetitive. But it is being presented as a whole play, and that brings some expectations, like a plot, or character development. This would require more connective tissue, though, and the script doesn't give us that. We never see the women at a diner between stops, or crammed in the car together bickering over what to put on the radio. Hell, the script doesn't even allude to things happening between scenes! The most we get is the opening scene at the retirement community, but since nothing more is given as the play progresses, instead of characters, we get walking backstories.
Without the connective tissue of plot or character, the disparate monologues pull in their own directions and fragment the script. We go from Rita's raunchy, raucous recounting of a first time featuring a fire alarm to intermission, and when we come back, it's Viola's admission
... Show more...Moving beyond that, the script cannot contain its contradictions.
In essence, it is four monologues. Naturally, each monologue wants to feel a little different, so the show has a tonal range and doesn't feel repetitive. But it is being presented as a whole play, and that brings some expectations, like a plot, or character development. This would require more connective tissue, though, and the script doesn't give us that. We never see the women at a diner between stops, or crammed in the car together bickering over what to put on the radio. Hell, the script doesn't even allude to things happening between scenes! The most we get is the opening scene at the retirement community, but since nothing more is given as the play progresses, instead of characters, we get walking backstories.
Without the connective tissue of plot or character, the disparate monologues pull in their own directions and fragment the script. We go from Rita's raunchy, raucous recounting of a first time featuring a fire alarm to intermission, and when we come back, it's Viola's admission to being raped. It's a tonal mess.